Ian MacQuillin: Fundraising should be a career choice, not an accidentIan MacQuillin: Fundraising should be a career choice, not an accidentIan MacQuillin: Fundraising should be a career choice, not an accidentIan MacQuillin: Fundraising should be a career choice, not an accident
  • About us
  • Membership
  • EFA Certification
  • Fundraising Europe
  • News
  • Events
  • Resources
  • About us
  • Membership
  • EFA Certification
  • Fundraising Europe
  • News
  • Events
  • Resources
european_flag_waving
It’s back to school for the European institutions
September 9, 2020
Spanish street
Market spotlight: How the Spanish fundraising market is changing
October 7, 2020

Ian MacQuillin: Fundraising should be a career choice, not an accident

September 15, 2020
Categories
  • Expert View
  • Features
Tags
  • EFA certification
  • Fundraising Profession
  • Professional development
Compass

Image credit: Photo by Aron Visuals on Unsplash

Having carried out new research into the career pathways for fundraising, report author and founder of fundraising think tank Rogare, Ian MacQuillin argues that that there should be more formal career pathways into the profession.

If you are reading this, you’re almost certainly a fundraiser. And if you are a fundraiser, you probably never set out to become one. You probably – say it with me – ‘fell into fundraising by accident’.

If you didn’t find your way into fundraising though luck and happenstance, there’s a good chance you transferred from another sector, perhaps because selling widgets and commanding tanks lost some of its meaning.

But what you probably didn’t do is decide while you were at school that you wanted to become a fundraiser, and then study for the relevant qualifications to get you into the profession, or follow some other recognised entry pathway designed to equip you with the knowledge and skills you need to become competent in the role.

That’s because such pathways don’t exist. The reason so many fundraisers join the profession by ‘accident’ is because it is so hard to make a deliberate decision to do so.

There are diversity issues in not having a level playing field for entry to the fundraising profession. But that’s not the only problem.

Professor and fundraising researcher Beth Breeze reckons that only five per cent of the UK’s fundraising workforce choose fundraising as a first choice career. But that’s just the ones who made it. We have no idea how many other people choose fundraising, but can’t find a way in because their paths are always blocked by people transferring from other sectors and falling in accidentally, both of whom can bring skills and experiences that the first choice careerist probably doesn’t yet have.

Many people have said there is a skills shortage in fundraising. It’s been reported in the UK by NCVO and throughout Europe in EFA reports. But what we can’t be sure about is the nature of this skills shortage. It could be one of two possibilities.

It could be that there are enough people with the right skills, but they are not being matched to the right roles where their skills are most needed. This is known as a systems failure.

But it could be that people with the right skills are not entering the jobs marketing in the first place. A market failure.

The research that would show which of these two is the case in fundraising hasn’t yet been done. But you can work out from first principles that it’s very likely to be a market failure, simply because most fundraisers enter the profession without the skills and knowledge they need to hit the ground running, because there aren’t established pathways to equip them with these skills.

But not only that, once you have fallen into fundraising, there is no requirement that you take any course, training, qualification or CPD designed to provide you with those skills. Many of the fundraisers interviewed by Beth Breeze for her 2017 book The New Fundraisers told her they’d never once even read a book about fundraising – and it comes across that they’re quite proud of this fact.

Entry into fundraising is haphazard and random, while formal knowledge acquisition is equally haphazard, as well as being optional. This optional nature of knowledge acquisition sets fundraising apart from just about every other profession – such as law, accountancy and surveying – which require entrants to qualify as a practitioner.

Qualifying is not the same things as studying for a qualification, such as the certificates offered by EFA’s member bodies.

Qualification in a profession means the candidate professional is passed as fit to practice – usually by the professional institute – as a competent professional having gone through a formal process to assess their competence.

Competence, according to standard definitions, is the “ability to perform tasks and roles to the expected standard”, or a “proven ability to use knowledge, skills and personal, social and/or methodological abilities in work or study situations and in professional and personal development”.

In the absence of any such mandatory qualifying process, how do we know when new entrants to fundraising have become sufficiently competent? Come to that, how do we know the people already practising as fundraisers are competent?

I’ve said to anyone who will listen (and to plenty who won’t) that fundraising needs to professionalise. Part of this professionalisation process is putting in place a qualifying pathway that shows anyone who want to become a fundraiser what they need to do in order to first get into fundraising, and then become competent at it. And that is generally more than just doing a course with an exam at the end.

Without such a pathway, fundraising will always struggle to attract the right people with the right skills, and runs a massive risk of turning away – or not even seeing – perfectly capable and suitable people. We are failing those people if the best option we can give them of entering the profession is accident, chance or happenstance.

About Ian MacQuillin

Ian MacQuillin is the director of Rogare – The Fundraising Think Tank. He has recently completed a review of entry pathways into fundraising for Arts Philanthropy & Fundraising and Cause4 in the UK, which is available here. 

 

Share

Related posts

TikTok
April 7, 2021

Your Voice: The rise and rise of TikTok, sharing insight from the British Red Cross


Read more
April 7, 2021

Zoe Amar: The road to recovery – what leaders need to do now


Read more
Euros
April 7, 2021

Patrick Gibbels: New EU Anti Money Laundering proposal on its way


Read more

Sign up to our free monthly news and features

  • Latest news
  • Latest features
  • News from EFA
  • Fundraising Europe
  • Advertise with EFA

Search news by country or category

News by date

Popular topics

  • Research
  • Coronavirus
  • Professional development
  • Individual giving
  • Philanthropic trends
  • Digital
  • Legacies
  • Events
  • Collaboration
  • Tax incentives

Events Calendar

< April 2021 >
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7AEFR Inbound Marketing Strategy Series (Spanish) all day
Session 4: Analysis of results
Online
81st Fundraising Conference for Health & Hospitality (French) all day
One day conference. AFF Fundraisers
Multi-Channel Fundraising (German) all day
Fundraising Verband Austria (Online Seminar)
9 10 11
12 13 14 15Fundraising from abroad (English & French) all day
Roundtable event (online)
Chapel & York
16 17 18
19 20ERNOP Seminar: Engaging with family business all day
(English)
21 22Leadership & Strategic Thinking (English) all day
Central & Eastern European Leadership Development Database fundraising (German) all day
Fundraising Verband Austria (Online Seminar)
Fundraising F***-Ups (English) from 3:00 pm to 4:30 pm
Conference
Online (Fundraisers Alliance Belgium)
23 24 25
26Fundraising Compact - Part 1 (German) all day
4 day training course
Online (Fundraising Verband Austria) Fundraising for Beginners (German) all day
Fundraising Verband Austria (Live Online Training)
26 April - 07 May 2021
27Fundraising Compact - Part 1 (German) all day
4 day training course
Online (Fundraising Verband Austria) Major Donor Fundraising (German) all day
Fundraising Verband Austria (Live Online Training)
Runs from 27 April to 22 June 2021
Online
28Institutional & Corporate Fundraising (German) all day
Fundraising Verband Seminar (Intensive 3-Day Online Seminar)
29Institutional & Corporate Fundraising (German) all day
Fundraising Verband Seminar (Intensive 3-Day Online Seminar)
30Institutional & Corporate Fundraising (German) all day
Fundraising Verband Seminar (Intensive 3-Day Online Seminar)
   

Registered Office

James Wattstraat 100
NL-1097 DM Amsterdam
Netherlands

EFA is registered at the Netherlands Chamber of Commerce
Reg. No. 34212817

Contact

Executive Officer, Denise Dawes
denise.dawes@efa-net.eu

Media enquiries:
news@efa-net.eu

Follow us

Twitter
Facebook
LinkedIn

Search

© 2021 EFA | European Fundraising Association. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy