Interview: What does Notre Dame tell us about French philanthropy?Interview: What does Notre Dame tell us about French philanthropy?Interview: What does Notre Dame tell us about French philanthropy?Interview: What does Notre Dame tell us about French philanthropy?
  • About us
  • Membership
  • EFA Certification
  • Fundraising Europe
  • News
  • Events
  • Resources
  • About us
  • Membership
  • EFA Certification
  • Fundraising Europe
  • News
  • Events
  • Resources
Heather Hill
Expert View: Why we need to speak up about donor dominance
May 15, 2019
Eduard Marcek
Your Voice: Taking on the mantle of strengthening civil society leadership
May 15, 2019

Interview: What does Notre Dame tell us about French philanthropy?

May 15, 2019
Categories
  • Features
  • France
Tags
  • Crowdfunding
notre dame

Fundraising for the restoration of the Notre Dame cathedral in Paris raised over €1 billion in just two days following the devastating fire, but critics argued that this money could have been put to better use. Fundraising Europe interviews Yaële Aferiat, Director of the French Fundraisers Association and Global Leader of Giving Tuesday in France.

 

In the immediate aftermath of the fire, funds poured in with hundreds of campaigns set up on crowdfunding sites GoFundMe and JustGiving, as well as €500m from the three billionaire families that own France’s giant luxury goods empires: Kering, LVMH and L’Oreal. French energy company Total has also given €100m. French president Emmanuel Macron pledged that Notre Dame would be rebuilt within five years and that French people would pull together to repair their national symbol.

But many commentators argued that there were more pressing concerns than the restoration of a cathedral, such as devastation to the planet and destruction of species. France’s Gilet Jaune movement also criticised the fact that so much money had been donated to restore the landmark, when in comparison little was being done to address the needs of low paid workers in the country.

Yaele Aferiat

Yaële Aferiat, French Fundraisers Association

[Fundraising Europe] Why were philanthropists so quick to rally round to provide funding to rebuild Notre Dame?
[Yaële Aferiat] For French philanthropists, as for donors all over the world, we believe this fire was a ‘one of a kind’ catastrophe. It’s not another earthquake, flood or outbreak of disease. There is no déjà-vu, no donor fatigue.  It’s a cathedral. One that has been standing as a symbol of Paris, of France, of the ability of men to build great and lasting monuments, for 800 years. And here it was going down in flames live on TV, showing the world – in real time – some horrifically beautiful images, with a very strong symbolism: the cathedral; the image of good, of God, of heaven, being attacked by a fire; the image of evil and hell. When a catastrophe happens, a natural human response is to ask what can be done and, as is often the case, giving was the answer.

As President Emmanuel Macron said during the evening of the fire “we will rebuild it”. Seeing the drama, everyone watching knew it would be an incredibly expensive task for a colossal piece of heritage that you can’t put a value on. The gifts of philanthropists were as high as the task in sight and the emotion of that night, maybe with a little dose of ego, but certainly also with a sense of historical responsibility. After all, throughout the centuries, philanthropists have helped finance cathedrals.

Why did this attract so much criticism from the public?
There are a number of reasons. First, the speed and the importance of the philanthropic response – 600 millions euros in one night – is unheard of in France where philanthropists tend to be very discreet. People wondered: if they can do it for Notre Dame, why not end homelessness or another social need? They understood that philanthropists have the resources and ability to support urgent causes, but choose not to. After weeks and weeks of Yellow Vests movement and a national debate on inequality, it was not well received.

The Abbé Pierre Foundation, helping people in need find decent housing, was the first to tweet about this, saying: “well done to our philanthropist[s] for Notre Dame, but maybe you could give a fraction to help us?”

This opens the interesting but controversial topic of whether there is a hierarchy amongst causes. There is also the concern that these very large gifts can also make the average person feel a little irrelevant.  What will my 10 euros gift accomplish in comparison? Many questions were raised about the fiscal deductibility of those big gifts. After all philanthropists were getting the glory without paying the full price as gifts are supposedly deductible at 66% from your taxes. This led François Pinault and Bernard Arnault to publicly announce that they were not going to claim the deduction. This was a first in France.

Are we ready for major donor philanthropy in France ?
All those controversies show that we still struggle a bit with the way we welcome major donors in our country. Here, the catholic tradition of “Good doesn’t make noise, and noise doesn’t do any good” is still very strongly embedded in people’s beliefs. People who have money – enough to part with major gifts – are often greeted with suspicion. Have they earned it fair and square? Do they pay their taxes?

In that context, capital campaigns developed rather recently here and we still have to build a real philanthropic culture. Explaining more and better, to the media, to state representatives, to the general public, and maybe to some non profit organisations who are not trying to attract big gifts. This means bringing more philanthropists to explain who they are and why they are doing it. To show the impact of their philanthropic actions. The Notre Dame fire could really be a wake up call for our sector.

What does this tell us about what donors are looking for from their philanthropic choices? What can fundraisers learn from this?
Was donating to rebuild Notre Dame really a philanthropic choice? It cannot be compared to a well thought out direction for a specific foundation or social need. Maybe the real lesson here is that, in our era of live information and social networks, anything can become an emergency, raising crazy amounts of money in a few hours. This used to be the traditional field of humanitarian charities. They are prepared for it.

Of course, the Fondation du Patrimoine (french cultural heritage foundation), who raises funds for the conservation of old churches, fountains or bridges all around France, never saw this coming. Many campaigns – some honest and some fraudulent ones too – were launched anonymously on crowdfunding websites all around the world in the hour following the beginning of the fire. However, the foundation was not able to announce the launch of their official fundraising campaign until late that evening, saying it would open the following morning. Their website crashed for hours and they probably missed a lot of donations in that time. You cannot ask people who sit feeling helpless and watching a catastrophe unfold to delay their gift.

 

About Yaële Aferiat

Yaële is director of the French Fundraisers Association (AFF) and Global Leader of Giving Tuesday in France. She is dedicated towards development of the fundraising profession and inspiring a culture of philanthropy in France.

 

 

 

Share

Related posts

February 10, 2021

Special focus: Transforming fundraising with digital


Read more
February 10, 2021

Patrick Gibbels: New EU Privacy laws are gaining momentum


Read more
Crystal ball
January 13, 2021

Looking into the crystal ball: Fundraising in 2021


Read more

Sign up to our free monthly news and features

  • Latest news
  • Latest features
  • News from EFA
  • Fundraising Europe
  • Advertise with EFA

Search news by country or category

News by date

Popular topics

  • Research
  • Coronavirus
  • Professional development
  • Individual giving
  • Philanthropic trends
  • Digital
  • Events
  • Legacies
  • Collaboration
  • Tax incentives

Events Calendar

< March 2021 >
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2Nonprofit Day 2021 / La grande sfida del nonprofit (Eng/It) all day
Conference
Online (Festival del fundraising)
3 4Nonprofit Women Camp (Italian) all day
Three-day online event
Nonprofit Women Camp Committee Marketing & Fundraising: Two sides of the same coin? (Dutch) from 9:30 am to 12:30 pm
Masterclass
Online (Fundraisers Alliance Belgium)
5Nonprofit Women Camp (Italian) all day
Three-day online event
Nonprofit Women Camp Committee
6Nonprofit Women Camp (Italian) all day
Three-day online event
Nonprofit Women Camp Committee
7
8 9Case for Support (German) all day
Fundraising Verband Austria (Online Seminar)
Data Driven Fundraising (Dutch) from 9:30 am to 3:30 pm
Masterclass
Online (Fundraisers Alliance Belgium)
10AEFR Inbound Marketing Strategy Series (Spanish) all day
Session 2: Donor recruitment
Online Seminar
11Legacy Fundraising Webinar (English) from 9:00 am to 12:30 pm
Richard Radcliffe: Legacy Fundraising - How to do it right and successfully
NPO Academy
Online
12Legacy Fundraising Webinar (English) from 9:00 am to 12:30 pm
Richard Radcliffe: Legacy Fundraising - How to do it right and successfully
NPO Academy
Online
13 14
15 1615th Fundraising Conference for Higher Education (French) all day
3-day online conference
AFF Fundraisers
17Insamlingsforum Online 2021 (Swedish / English) all day
Two-day annual conference (Giva Sverige / Give Sweden)
Online
18 19 20 21
22 23Content Marketing for Nonprofits (German) all day
Fundraising Verband Austria (Online Seminar)
ERNOP Seminar: Sustaining Voluntary Energy (English) from 10:00 am to 11:00 am
Seminar by Professor Lucas Meys from the Rotterdam School of Management
Online CFRE Webinar: How to become a CFRE in EMEA (English) from 1:00 pm to 2:00 pm
Webinar
24AEFR Inbound Marketing Strategy Series (Spanish) all day
Seminar 3: Education, Closure & Loyalty
Online Diploma in Fundraising (English) all day
CIOF: Fundraising Diploma (One year course, flexible study time, fixed assignment deadlines and exam date)
Booking deadline: 3rd March
25 26 27 28
293rd Digital Social Summit (German) all day
Two-day online conference organised by the Bürgerermut Foundation
30 31        

Registered Office

James Wattstraat 100
NL-1097 DM Amsterdam
Netherlands

EFA is registered at the Netherlands Chamber of Commerce
Reg. No. 34212817

Contact

Executive Officer, Denise Dawes
denise.dawes@efa-net.eu

Media enquiries:
news@efa-net.eu

Follow us

Twitter
Facebook
LinkedIn

Search

© 2021 EFA | European Fundraising Association. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy